Nobody wants your ideas


A few weeks ago someone offered me a deal:

“Kyle, I have an amazing idea, and I can tell you have the creativity to pull it off.
How about we partner up and split the proceeds?”

I’ve been offered this same deal a hundred times. It always goes something like this:

  • “I’ve got a great idea for a book, but I need someone to write it.”
  • “I’ve got a great idea for a product, but I need someone to build it.”
  • “I’ve got a great idea for a business, but I need someone to start it.”

In other words: “I’ll have the idea, you’ll do all the work, and we’ll split everything 50/50.”

If you ask these people what the idea actually is, they get cagey. They’ll ask you to sign an NDA or pinky-promise not to steal it, as if they’re about to launch the next iPhone.

I find that hilarious, because frankly, nobody wants your ideas.

What people want is for you to solve their problems.

Ideas can solve those problems, but only if someone takes those ideas and makes them real.

An idea on its own is worth essentially nothing.

Just to prove it, here are some amazing ideas that I will give you, absolutely free:

  1. A robot that does your laundry.
  2. A machine that turns garbage into diamonds.
  3. A device that beams food to hungry people worldwide.

Those are all great ideas. Every one of them would profoundly change the world.

The problem is, I don’t know how to make any of those ideas work. And until someone figures that out, they’re worthless.

Ideas are the easy part. It’s the execution that’s hard.

The real threat to your ideas isn’t someone else — it’s you. The real threat is not that your ideas will get stolen, but that they will sit on a shelf and crumble away to nothing because you never put in the hard work to bring those ideas to life.

The world doesn’t want your ideas. It wants you to turn them into real things — businesses, books, products, poems, songs — that solve real problems for real people.

That process is scary and vulnerable and full of obstacles. But it’s also the only way your ideas will ever make a real difference in the world. It’s the only way your ideas ever become worth anything.

The danger isn’t “What if someone steals my idea?”
The real danger is “What if I never do anything with it?

-Kyle

Kyle Scheele

One useful idea about creative leadership, once a week

Read more from Kyle Scheele

I’ve noticed something interesting about our society’s approach to creativity: we punish it in children and praise it in adults. When adults find creative solutions, they often get rewarded with praise, promotions, or new opportunities. But when children find creative solutions for things, they are often punished. This happened to me all the time as a kid. In high school, I once organized an impromptu fundraiser to buy a gorilla suit (it’s a long story). That afternoon, I got called down to...

They say that you should tackle your most important tasks at the beginning of each day. That way, if things go sideways later, you’ve already accomplished your biggest priority. Which is why, every morning since late 2021, I start my day with Wordle. If you’ve never played Wordle, here’s the gist: Each day, you have six chances to guess a five-letter word. After each guess, the game gives you three colors of feedback: GREY means the letter isn’t in the word. YELLOW means it’s in the word, but...

This week I had three speaking events in 28 hours on opposite sides of the country. Last week I did four events in four cities in five days. It’s the busy season for speakers, and the question I get a lot is, “What about work/life balance?” I love that question, because it allows me to share one of my favorite hot takes: Work/life balance is a myth. It doesn’t exist! At least, it doesn’t exist in the way I often hear people talk about it. People talk about work/life balance as if it is a...