"My job is to buy lottery tickets"


Several years ago I was talking to an acquiring editor at HarperCollins. I was asking him about the particulars of his job, and he shared something in a moment of honesty:

“Kyle, my job is to buy lottery tickets. Every book I acquire is a lottery ticket. I know most of them won’t be winners, but if the winners offset the losers, I get to keep my job.”

To be clear, he wasn’t saying that he just acquires books at random and hopes for the best. On the contrary, he told me he works very hard to find good books, and he tries his best to be a good steward of his publisher’s resources. But even so, experience has taught him there are no guarantees in the book business.

I think creative projects work the same way.

Each of my creative projects is a lottery ticket. Like my editor friend, I try to pick projects that I think have the highest chance of success. But experience has taught me (sometimes painfully) that there are no guaranteed winners.

Sometimes I will work extraordinarily hard on a project, only to have it launch to crickets. Other times I will put almost no effort into a project and it will go viral. I’ve tried to figure out what makes the difference, but so far I’ve found no smoking gun.

There’s a difference between my lottery tickets and my publisher’s, though: Mine are much cheaper.

An acquiring editor has to spend tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars to buy a book and bring it to market. But for creative projects, the cost is often negligible. If anything, the highest cost is usually time.

There are lots of things that work this way, too.

Social media posts are lottery tickets. So are new jokes or stories you try onstage.

Cold-emailing someone you admire is a way of buying a lottery ticket, and so is pitching an idea in a meeting.

Individually, each one has a minuscule chance of changing your life. But if you keep stacking attempts, you increase your chances of hitting the jackpot. And as long as the winners offset the losers, you get to keep playing the game.

The good news is, when the only cost of a lottery ticket is a bit of courage and time, you can afford to lose most of your bets.

So how many tickets are you buying?

Happy Friday, friends. Make it a good one.

Kyle Scheele
Helping Launch Better Ideas, Faster
www.KyleScheele.com

P.S. Speaking of lottery tickets, I could use your help with one I'm betting big on. My next book, How Ideas Work, comes out in January. If you want to stop waiting on inspiration and start generating great ideas and bringing them to life, this book will show you how. Preorders are open now!

Kyle Scheele

One useful idea about creative leadership, once a week

Read more from Kyle Scheele

Lately I’ve been spending less time online, but not for the reasons you might expect. I’m not cutting back because I’m concerned about screen time or blue light or the cumulative effects of doomscrolling on the human psyche (although those are all good reasons, too). I’m cutting back because it’s a competitive advantage. I’m an ideas guy. (It’s kind of my whole thing, actually.) But contrary to common creative mythology, ideas don’t just pop into existence. They’re made from other ideas. The...

When I was 17, I wrecked my girlfriend’s car. We were driving around aimlessly, because that’s all I could really afford to do. We took her Durango, because it was nicer than my car, but she liked me to drive, so I drove. Right into a pole. In my defense, the pole was basically asking to be driven into. It was a short metal pipe, painted black (incidentally, the same color as the parking lot), and it sat low enough that you could easily miss it if you were in a car that sat a little higher...

There’s a common piece of advice that says “Never meet your heroes, because they’re sure to disappoint you.” Personally, I couldn’t disagree more. Over the years, I’ve gotten to meet a lot of my heroes: bestselling authors, prolific creators, and all sorts of other cool people who are putting incredible work into the world. Almost without fail, these people have turned out to be even cooler in real life than I’d built them up to be in my head. But they’ve also disappointed me, and that's been...